by LawInc Staff
May 22, 2024
Starting a business and growing it into a successful enterprise ready for an Initial Public Offering (IPO) requires navigating a complex legal landscape. Key legal considerations arise at each stage – from entity type considerations to intellectual property, hiring employees, securing funding, and preparing for the rigorous IPO process. Astute entrepreneurs tap skilled attorneys well versed in startup law to guide them in making sound decisions and avoiding pitfalls on the path from idea to IPO.
This guide examines the essential legal areas entrepreneurs must address to successfully launch and scale their ventures up through a potential IPO. We detail entity formation options, funding legalities, intellectual property strategies, employment law compliance, and exit preparation. Armed with this knowledge, founders can tap the right legal partners to maximize their odds of startup success.
1. Choosing the Right Business Structure
-
- Sole Proprietorship: Simple to form but lacks liability protection or easy ownership transfer.
- Partnership: Easy to establish but partners share personal liability for business debts.
- Limited Liability Company (LLC): Provides liability protection with pass-through taxation.
- C Corporation: Separate legal entity offering liability protection but subject to double taxation.
- S Corporation: Avoids double taxation of C corps while providing liability protection.
Examples:
-
- Kate formed a sole proprietorship for her web design freelancing due to its ease and low cost.
- The mobile app cofounders created an LLC to protect their personal assets as the business grew.
- The biotech startup chose C corp status to enable issuing multiple stock classes to investors.
- The profitable small business converted to an S corp to avoid double taxation.
- The legal practice formed a limited liability partnership balancing protection and taxation.
How to Proceed:
-
- Consult an attorney and accountant on the tax and legal implications of each entity type.
- Choose a structure aligned with your growth stage, business model, and fundraising needs.
- File required paperwork with state agencies to legally form your entity.
- Create governing documents like operating agreements and shareholder agreements.
- Obtain necessary licenses and permits to operate your business legally.
FAQs:
-
- Can I change my business structure later? Yes, but it may have tax and legal consequences.
- Which entity is best for attracting investors? C corps are the most common for high-growth startups.
- Do I need an attorney to form an LLC? Not required but highly recommended to ensure compliance.
- What’s the difference between an LLC and S corp? Mainly in taxation, ownership restrictions and formalities.
- How long does it take to form a corporation? A few days to weeks depending on your state.
2. Protecting Intellectual Property
-
- Patents: Protect inventions and processes granting a 20 year exclusivity period.
- Trademarks: Protect brand names, logos and slogans distinguishing your company.
- Copyrights: Protect original works of authorship like software code, content, images, etc.
- Trade Secrets: Protect confidential business information through NDAs and other safeguards.
- Licensing Agreements: Enable monetizing IP assets in partnership with other entities.
Examples:
-
- The medical device startup patented its novel surgical tool to prevent copycat products.
- The fintech venture trademarked its brand and logo to build a distinct identity in a crowded sector.
- The mobile gaming studio secured copyrights on its proprietary game engine code.
- The AI company required employee NDAs to protect its machine learning trade secrets.
- The biotech firm licensed its drug compound IP to a big pharma partner for development.
How to Proceed:
-
- Consult an IP attorney to determine which protections best suit your business needs.
- File patents, trademarks, and copyrights with the USPTO and US Copyright Office.
- Establish internal policies to safeguard trade secrets and confidential data.
- Implement NDAs, invention assignment and IP clauses in employee/contractor agreements.
- Explore potential licensing deals to accelerate development or tap new verticals.
FAQs:
-
- How long does the patent process take? On average 2-3 years from application to approval.
- Is my startup’s name automatically trademarked? No, trademarks require formal registration.
- Can I copyright my website? You can copyright the content, images, graphics, not the HTML.
- What happens if an employee leaks trade secrets? You can sue for damages and an injunction.
- Do I need an IP attorney for licensing deals? Absolutely, to negotiate favorable terms and contracts.
3. Navigating Employment Law
-
- Employee Classification: Determine if workers are employees or independent contractors.
- Employment Agreements: Define roles, responsibilities, compensation, benefits, termination conditions.
- Anti-Discrimination Laws: Prohibit bias based on age, race, gender, disability, etc.
- Wage and Hour Regulations: Govern minimum wage, overtime, meal breaks and paystubs.
- Workplace Safety Standards: Require employers to provide safe, hazard-free work environments.
Examples:
-
- The startup classified some staff as contractors to minimize overhead and liability.
- The growing business used employment agreements to define key roles and equity compensation.
- The tech company implemented anti-bias training and reporting channels to foster an inclusive culture.
- The restaurant chain deployed software to ensure proper calculation of overtime and breaks.
- The construction firm provided protective gear and safety protocol training to all job site workers.
How to Proceed:
-
- Classify workers properly as employees or contractors per IRS and state rules.
- Establish comprehensive employment agreements reviewed by a knowledgeable attorney.
- Create an employee handbook detailing company policies, benefits and behavioral expectations.
- Use an HRIS to accurately track employee time, PTO and payroll in line with wage laws.
- Document and promptly investigate any claims of discrimination, harassment or unsafe conditions.
FAQs:
-
- Should at-will employment clauses be in offer letters? Yes, to preserve flexibility unless you offer guaranteed terms.
- Do workplace anti-discrimination laws apply to my small startup? Often only if you have 15+ employees but always wise to comply.
- Are salary discussions between employees protected? No, employers can restrict wage discussions but can’t retaliate if they occur.
- What are the penalties for worker misclassification? Back taxes, fines, legal damages and even criminal charges.
- Can we fire underperforming staff at will? Assuming at-will status, yes, if reason is non-discriminatory and well-documented.
4. Securing Funding Legally
-
- Convertible Notes: Short-term debt that converts to equity in a later round.
- SAFEs: Like convertible notes but not a debt instrument, just the right to future equity.
- Priced Equity Rounds: Selling shares of stock to investors at a fixed valuation.
- Venture Debt: Loans often used as supplement to equity financing or bridge between rounds.
- Crowdfunding: Raising small amounts of capital from a large number of people, typically online.
Examples:
-
- The early stage startup used a convertible note to raise a quick $500K to hit milestones.
- The founders chose a SAFE over a note to simplify the seed fundraise and cap table.
- The Series A round let the startup sell 20% of the company to VCs for $5M.
- The startup took out $2M in venture debt to extend its runway before the next equity round.
- The hardware startup raised $1M from 5000 pre-orders in a rewards crowdfunding campaign.
How to Proceed:
-
- Determine how much capital you need to raise and for what purposes.
- Choose funding instruments that align with your stage, growth trajectory, and exit goals.
- Comply with SEC regulations on accredited investors, disclosures and general solicitation.
- Consult legal counsel to draft deal documents like term sheets, stock purchase agreements, etc.
- Perform due diligence on investors’ background, track record and strategic value-add.
FAQs:
-
- What’s the difference between equity and convertible debt? Debt has a maturity date and interest, equity means company ownership.
- Do I need to be profitable to raise equity funding? No, investors fund growth potential and often expect years of losses.
- How do I determine my startup’s valuation? Early on by supply and demand, later via revenue and growth rate comps.
- What legal docs do I need for a seed round? Term sheet, stock purchase agreement, investor rights agreement, etc.
- What’s the downside of venture debt? It accrues interest, has a maturity date, and is senior to equity.
5. Preparing for an IPO or Acquisition
-
- Due Diligence: Extensive review of financials, contracts, IP, legal compliance, etc.
- S-1 Registration: Detailed document filed with the SEC outlining the company’s plans and risks.
- Sarbanes-Oxley Compliance: Meeting strict financial reporting and disclosure requirements.
- Merger Agreements: Contracts specifying terms of company combinations like target, consideration, warranties.
- Lock-up Periods: Preventing insiders from selling shares for a set time post-IPO, typically 180 days.
Examples:
-
- The unicorn startup spent months undergoing rigorous audits before pursuing an IPO.
- The SaaS company registered its S-1 prospectus detailing growth plans and competition risks.
- The public company invested millions in SOX compliance software and financial controls.
- The tech giants’ merger agreement outlined a $10B all-stock transaction and key personnel retention.
- The newly public company’s investors had to wait 6 months post-IPO to sell their shares.
How to Proceed:
-
- Choose experienced IPO or M&A counsel and underwriters/bankers to guide you through the process.
- Get your financials, corporate governance and regulatory compliance in order well in advance.
- Perform your own due diligence to surface and rectify any red flags before third party audits.
- Align stakeholders on key deal parameters and anticipate investor or regulator pushback.
- Communicate transparently and manage expectations both internally and externally.
FAQs:
-
- How long does an IPO take? At least 6-9 months from initial S-1 filing to shares trading on exchange.
- What’s the difference between a merger and acquisition? Consolidation into a new company vs. one buying the other.
- Do I have to accept the highest acquisition offer? No, the board has a duty to get the best deal but that’s not always the most cash.
- When do I need to start SOX compliance? When you file to go public or reach $10M in revenue.
- What can go wrong during the IPO process? Weak financials, regulatory issues, market volatility, and poor storytelling.
Summary
Starting and scaling a successful business requires astute navigation of critical legal issues from inception through exit. Founders need expert counsel to choose the right entity, protect IP assets, comply with employment and funding regulations, and prepare for lucrative acquisitions or IPOs.
But being legally buttoned up is just the beginning. Leading entrepreneurs build value fast by developing disruptive products, assembling top talent, and structuring scalable operations. Choosing creative and pragmatic attorneys who can pivot quickly and offer strategic guidance, not just risk management, is a true competitive advantage in today’s breakneck startup landscape.
Need a Startup Lawyer? Contact Us
If you’re launching a new venture or facing growth-stage legal issues, contact our firm for a free consultation with an experienced startup attorney. From founders’ agreements to fundraising to exit planning, we offer the tailored legal services and practical business advice you need to succeed.
Test your startup legal savvy
Questions: Key Contract Considerations for Startups
-
- 1. What’s the most important clause in a founder agreement?
- A) Non-compete
- B) IP assignment
- C) Equity vesting
- D) Capital contribution
- 2. What should a good employee offer letter include?
- A) Job duties
- B) Compensation
- C) Benefits
- D) All of the above
- 3. What’s a key issue to address in a lease agreement?
- A) Rent abatement
- B) Subletting rights
- C) Security deposit
- D) All of the above
- 4. What should a customer contract warrant?
- A) Product quality
- B) On-time delivery
- C) IP non-infringement
- D) All of the above
- 5. What’s most important to include in an NDA?
- A) Definition of confidential info
- B) Time limit on confidentiality
- C) Exclusions from confidentiality
- D) All of the above
- 1. What’s the most important clause in a founder agreement?
Answers: Key Contract Considerations for Startups
-
- 1. C) Equity vesting is the most critical to incentivize performance and avoid giving away too much too soon.
- 2. D) A solid employment offer letter should spell out all key terms of the role and compensation clearly.
- 3. D) Negotiating free rent, subletting flexibility, and deposit terms can help a startup conserve cash.
- 4. D) Standing behind your product’s quality, timeliness, and IP integrity builds customer trust.
- 5. D) An airtight NDA needs clear definitions, time limits, and exceptions to be reliably enforceable.
Questions: Navigating Founder Legal Disputes
-
- 1. Which is not a common legal dispute among startup founders?
- A) Equity ownership
- B) IP rights
- C) Overtime pay
- D) Breach of fiduciary duty
- 2. What’s a legal reason to remove a cofounder?
- A) Poor performance
- B) Misconduct
- C) Conflict of interest
- D) All of the above
- 3. What’s a common symptom of minority shareholder oppression?
- A) Excessive executive pay
- B) Withholding distributions
- C) Dilutive financing
- D) All of the above
- 4. What legal action can a founder take if forced out?
- A) Sue for breach of contract
- B) File for wrongful termination
- C) Seek appraisal rights
- D) All of the above
- 5. What’s the typical time limit to bring a breach of fiduciary duty claim?
- A) 1 year
- B) 2 years
- C) 3 years
- D) 4 years
- 1. Which is not a common legal dispute among startup founders?
Answers: Navigating Founder Legal Disputes
-
- 1. C) Wage and hour claims are more commonly employee v. employer than among founders.
- 2. D) Poor performance, misconduct, and conflicts can all justify founder removal if well-documented.
- 3. D) Excessive pay, withheld distributions, and dilutive rounds are all red flags of minority oppression.
- 4. D) Forced-out founders may have contract, wrongful termination, and appraisal right claims.
- 5. D) Most states give plaintiffs up to 4 years to bring breach of fiduciary duty lawsuits.
Disclaimer
This startup law overview is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute specific legal advice. Consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on particular matters. The author and publisher disclaim any liability for decisions or outcomes resulting from reliance on this content. Laws change frequently and vary by location, so verify the current rules and regulations relevant to your situation. Neither the quizzes nor the FAQ responses are intended as a substitute for individualized legal counsel. Use this information at your own risk.
Also See
Los Angeles Business Formation: Your Legal Guide from Hollywood to Silicon Beach